Lokeさんの講義のmotion

09/09/18 haruna

Motions in Sept 2009

MMU Ramadhan IV 2009 Motions, Sept 09, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

---

担当　谷口

Rd1: THW pay adult children to take care of their elderly parents

Rd2: THBT religious authorities should have the right to sanction personal sins

Rd3: THW make the price of plane tickets dependent on a person's weight

Rd4: THBT a settlement with the Taliban is the best solution to the Afghan problem

Qtrs: THW make third world aid dependent on birth control

Semis: TH regrets sending back the Lockerbie bomber

Finals: THW criminalize adultery

---

Asian Schools’ Debating Championships 2009, Sept 09, De La Salle U, Manila, Philippines

担当　満園

The Theme for Round 1 is EDUCATION.
1. THBT teacher's pay should be based on student's performance
2. THW allow schools to punish students by conducting public caning.
3. THW ban the sale of Junk Food in Schools.

Theme for Round 2: The Purple Rainbow
1.THW disallow private Catholic Schools from firing homosexual teachers
2.THW include homosexuality in compulsory sex education programs in school
3.THW not allow openly gay individuals to hold key military positions

---

担当　永島

Theme for Round 3: The Oriental Dragon
1. This house believes that it is finally time to expel Myanmar from ASEAN
2. This house believes that America should remove its guarantee of military support for Taiwan
3. This house believes that Google should not participate in internet censorship in China.

Theme for Round 4: Moral Dilemmas
1. This house believes that parents should not decide on the sexual assignment of their inter-sexed infants
2. This house believes that police officers should not be allowed to entrap paedophiles
3. This house would compel doctors to report signs of marital abuse

---

担当　柴原

Theme for Round 5: Pop Culture
1. This house regrets the popularity of films that parody the Holocaust
2. This house believes that record companies should make contract renewal of pop stars contingent on good conduct
3. This house condemns the unfair editing of reality TV shows

Theme for Round 6: Classics with a Twist
1. This house would extend the death penalty to minors
2. This house believes that convicted drunk drivers should be banned from drinking ever again
3. This house would ban celebrities from running for elections

----

担当　橘

Theme for Round 7: Women
This house would decline fertility assistance to the poor
This house believes that the state should force men to provide child support for unwanted pregnancies
This house believes that liquor companies should not market their alcohol with women.

Octo-Finals Theme: Health
1. This house would make fitness class optional in schools
2. This house believes that health insurance should also cover illegal immigrants
3. This house would prevent religious institutions from influencing laws regarding health

---

担当　荒木

Quarter-Finals Theme: Military
1. THBT parents have a right to enlist their children as freedom fighters against an oppressive state
2. THBT would not allow the military to offer scholarships as incentives to be enlisted
3. THBT Soldiers should be allowed to withdraw from fighting on religious grounds

Semi-Finals Theme: The Law
1. This house would ban the cross-examination of a rape victim’s sexual history
2. This house believes that the state should appoint all expert witnesses

Finals Motion: This house would deny non tax-paying citizens the right to vote

---

World Online Debating Championships 2009

担当　松林

QF1: Mexico v Estonia,
Motion: Pre-nuptial agreements should not be recognised in divorce courts
QF2: Latvia v South Korea,
Motion: Heavy drinkers should be denied liver transplants
QF3: England v Venezuela,
Motion: Rich countries should actively recruit medical personnel from poorer countries
QF4: South Africa v Lithuania,
Motion: Interest rates on personal lending should be capped by law at 20%.

Preliminary Rounds

1. All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.
2. Dictatorship is the best path to development.

---

担当　小林

3. All patents should be removed on anti retroviral drugs to fight aids.
4. Convicted paedophiles should be chemically castrated.
5. Same sex marriage should be legal.

6. Western powers should leave Afghanistan.

7. All drugs should be decriminalised.

---

担当　赤木

8. The UN should impose sanctions on countries which destroy their rainforest.

9. Leaders of countries that use extra territorial rendition should be tried for War Crimes.

10. All taxes on inherited wealth should be abolished.

11. Poorer Countries should abandon Free Trade Agreements.

12. All forms of gambling should be banned.