岩田、太田チーム 反対立論

作成者:1年岩田

【反対立論原稿】
Thank you ladies and gentlemen. Now, under the status quo, Japan is suffering from the lack of electricity, and japan depends on nuclear power generation very largely. Because nuclear power generation is the vital energy source for japan, it is impossible to abolish nuclear power generation and promote alternative energy resources. In addition, abolishing nuclear power generation will cause economic problems. In my speech, there are three arguments.I will explain one by one.


Our first argument is the problems of alternative energy resources. If japan abolish nuclear power generation, it will have to promote alternative energy resources. According to Mr.Baba, a business consultant, about 70% of Japanese natural energy is produced by hydroelectric power generation, and about 30% is produced by biomass generation. However, the rate of other generations such as solar generation or wind generation is less than 1%. He says it is impossible to promote hydroelectric generation or biomass generation any more. This is because most Japanese land which is suitable for hydroelectric power generation is already used, and cheap biomass fuels are decreasing. Therefore, Japan will have to depend on wind generation or solar generation. However these generations have so many problems. According to sankei news, 2011.7.11, solar power generation cost three times as much as thermal power generation. Mr.Son, the president of softbank proposed a plan to introduce solar panels in 100 million households. This will cost 12 trillion yen, which will finally become the burden on people. Wind generation has problems too. Japan is not suitable to make wind generation because japan is a small countriy and typhoons come to japan so frequently. It will cost too much to use Japanese small and mountainous land for wind generation. As I explained alternative energy resources have so many problems. .


Our second argument is green house gases. In general, nuclear power generation is said to emit less CO2. Japan is now trying to reduce CO2 emission. If japan abandon nuclear power generation, japan will have to depend on thermal power generation, which emits more CO2 than other ways. According to Yomiurishinbun, 2011.6.8, if japan abandon all nuclear power plants and use thermal power plants for the loss, CO2 emission will increase by about 15% in 2020. Japan set a goal to reduce CO2 emission by 25% by 2020. If japan abandon nuclear power generation, japan will be unable to achieve this goal. If japan lower the goal, japan will send a message that japan doesn't mind environmental problems, and lose international trust, and finally lose its power in the world community.


Our third argument is impact on the economy. According to the researches by fujitsu, electricity charges will increase by 19.4% in 2012, and the increase of electricity charges per one household will be about 23,000 yen per year. According to the Minister in Charge of Economic and Fiscal Policy, Mr.Yosano says if japan abandons nuclear power generation, Japanese GDP will decrease. After taking this proposal, japan will have to import more and more fossil fuels and Japanese money will spread to other countries, and Japanese GDP will decrease. According to him, if stable electricity supply stops after abolishing nuclear power generation, companies may move to other countries where they can get stable electricity and cheap labor, and in this point, GDP will decrease too. According to hokuriku electronic company, Japan imports uranium mainly from Australia or Canada. These countries are politically stable. However, Japan imports fossil fuels from a small number of countries, most of which are developing countries. Therefore, if these countries stop exporting fossil fuels , japan will be unable to ensure enough electricity and will be forced to suffer from serious lack of electricity. Finally Japanese electricity charges will increase, and consumption will be weak, and Japanese economy will be worse.


Finally, I want to summarize my speech. As I explained, if Japan abandon nuclear power generation, many problems will happen, and these problems will finally lead to economic problems. In order to avoid such problems, japan shouldn't abandon nuclear power generation. Thank you for listening.

第2アーギュメントを中心に一部修正を加えました。Affirmativeの定義次第で、第一アーギュメントは無効になるので、その場合はHuman Errorについてのアーギュメントで代替するつもりです。

Nov 24 By Captain

編集方法について
去年も確か、変な感じになった記憶があります
ピンクの網掛けの部分が出てきて、文章が横にブワーって表示されるんですね。
で、適当にいじってみたところ、行頭を半角一文字空けると、そのように表示されることが判明しました。
今は、きれいに表示されているはずです。
ですので、他の方にも言えますが、記入するときは行頭を詰めてください。
一文字分空けて書き始めなくて結構です。
改行さえすれば、段落の区切れは分かります。
英語の授業で習ったフォーマットとは違うかもしれませんが、それでおねがいします。

内容については後程コメントします。

タグ:

+ タグ編集
  • タグ:

このサイトはreCAPTCHAによって保護されており、Googleの プライバシーポリシー利用規約 が適用されます。

最終更新:2011年11月29日 15:37
ツールボックス

下から選んでください:

新しいページを作成する
ヘルプ / FAQ もご覧ください。